KIM SEJEONG’s Top or Cliff is nominated for Best R&B Song and Door is nominated for Best Album in the 2023 KPOPREVIEWED Awards. Support KIM SEJEONG’s releases and your other favourite acts by clicking here to vote today.

Following the surprising announcement of Gugudan’s disbandment in 2020, the only member that has managed to stay on my radar is Kim Sejeong. This is more so the result of her growing popularity through the Korean dramas Business Proposal and The Uncanny Encounter. In August of this year, she returned as a solo artist with her first studio album, Door, and the title tracks Top or Cliff and Voyage. The former is the focus of this review post.

Top or Cliff takes us down the R&B path, with a flowy melody and a dramatic instrumentation. The guitar work that kicks off the song has this grip to it, while the dramatic nature of the instrumentation comes to life via the very paced percussion we hear in the background. This all accumulates towards a mature and moody atmosphere. Unfortunately, Top or Cliff doesn’t deviate from this composition at all as the song progresses, which is good for consistency purposes, but it also makes the song feel flat and lackluster as it goes on. I wished there was some sort of concentration of intensity towards the end to make Top or Cliff even more memorable on the instrumental front. Kim Sejeong’s vocals was very soothing, which I found to both complement and contrast with the rest of Top or Cliff. An interesting predicament. The breathy nature of the vocals accentuates the melodies and contributes to the mature and moody atmosphere. Yet it is smooth despite the dramatic flair. Overall, Top or Cliff has the hallmarks of a strong release. But I feel like better development, trajectory and an ending would have made everything even better.

Matching the mature and moody atmosphere of the song is the dark and violent music video. I would say that it feels rather unexpected. But it is a memorable aspect of this comeback. The music video opens up with Kim Sejeong arriving at the mansion. The staff all lineup to greet her at her arrival, but from some of the scenes, there is a level of distrust between her and the staff. I suppose she has a high rank in whatever this organisation is, and the staff (as we see later in the video) are planning a revolt. The staff keeps an eye on her, but she clearly knows that something is happening around the mansion. In the end, she takes action herself and takes down all of the staff themselves. A fight breaks ensues, but ultimately Kim Sejeong wins and burns the place down. While there is a lot of bloodshed in this video, I do find the start of the video where she is dancing around the mansion to be quite aesthetically pleasing. But I am assuming this is supposed to be intention so that it looks like she doesn’t know what is going on. I believe the message, when taking the events of the video and the lyrics into account, shows her strength and determination to not show her weakness.

The performance is very flowy, matching up with the melodies of the song. It looks nice and feels pleasant to watch, but nothing memorable comes from it.

Song – 8/10
Music Video – 10/10
Performance – 8/10
Overall Rating – 8.6/10